Barristers, solicitors, bloggers and academics all love to read and analyse judgments. Law students, less so.
So do all Court of Protection and inherent jurisdiction cases end with a court judgment that’s published online? It may come as a surprise that actually very few end with a published judgment. That’s because they conclude by way of a final order agreed between the parties, or a decision of the court for which brief reasons are given but are not published as a judgment.
Recently, a complex coercive control cases concluded by way of an agreed final order. I represented the local authority. I thought it would be interesting to share a heavily anonymised version of the story, for readers to understand the typical steps of a elder abuse case in the Court of Protection.
Perpetrator tactics
I’ll call her Mrs Jones, an older lady who until April this year lived by herself in her home. Her husband died some years previously. But as a married couple, the two of them used to enjoy weekly bingo in the local town. They’d get there and back in a taxi, using the same driver each time.
When the husband died, the taxi driver befriended Mrs Jones, and used to run errands for her, for which she paid him. The taxi driver and his wife became more friendly and provided care to Mrs Jones as she grew older.
Mrs Jones’ family contacted adult social services when they noticed she’d turned against them, which was totally out of character. They noticed that her care needs were not being met, and that she was sometimes dehydrated and quite confused.
It then transpired that the taxi driver and his wife had arranged - via an online law firm(!) - for Mrs Jones to put her house, of which she was the sole owner, into a trust. The three trustees were Mrs Jones, the taxi driver, and his wife. Mrs Jones signed the various documents creating the trust and transferring her house into it.
The taxi driver had also arranged for Mrs Jones to change her will. The new will added the taxi driver as a beneficiary. Again, Mrs Jones signed the document.
The taxi couple also arranged for Mrs Jones to sign Lasting Powers of Attorney (LPAs), appointing the taxi driver and his wife as attorneys for Mrs Jones’ property and financial affairs, and for her health and welfare. A so-called “certificate provider” of an LPA is supposed to make sure that the person signing the LPA knows what they are signing. The certificate provider for Mrs Jones was the taxi driver’s good friend, who duly signed the documents.
In England and Wales, it’s astonishingly easy for a perpetrator to arrange for (or suggest, encourage, urge, persuade, cajole, coax, pressure, unduly influence, manipulate, guilt-trip, bully, intimidate, or threaten - pick your verb) a person to sign legal documents.
A short explainer about these legal documents which are commonly used by perpetrators of coercive control against vulnerable adults. The documents are ideal weapons of control, as they grant the controlling person legal power to make legally binding decisions for the victim.
The four documents in this case were:
LPA for property and financial affairs. This gives the controlling person access to P’s funds, immediately if P has ticked the correct box even while P retains capacity to make financial decisions.
LPA for health and welfare. This gives the controlling person the right to make decisions for P about where they live, what they do, activities they participate in. In my experience, it is commonly not understood that the power in this type of LPA can only start when P lacks capacity to make decisions about care.
A trust deed. This transfers ownership of the property to the controlling person.
A will. This lists the controlling person as a beneficiary of P’s estate. This means when P dies, their estate goes to the controlling person. Sometimes the controlling person is listed as the executor too (the executor administers the estate).
The Court of Protection
The local authority invited the taxi driver and (separately) his wife for a meeting with a senior social worker and a solicitor for the local authority. During the meeting, the local authority put to them the allegations of coercive control, fraud and abuse. The taxi driver denied the allegations, saying that Mrs Jones had made all the decisions herself and didn’t want her family involved, and he was only doing her a favour and following her wishes. His wife said she had no idea what was going on and didn’t read any of the documents her husband got her to sign. The meetings were recorded and transcripts were produced.
As the issues weren’t resolved, the local authority applied to the Court of Protection. The application included the transcript of the meetings with the taxi driver and his wife so that the court already had their accounts on record.
The court then made several administrative and substantive decisions.
The court appointed a litigation friend for Mrs Jones. Even though she lacked capacity to conduct the Court of Protection proceedings, the litigation friend ensured her voice, and her wishes and feelings, were always front and centre of the court’s decisions.
The court joined the taxi driver and his wife as parties. The court also joined Mrs Jones’ nephew: he acted as a sort of spokesperson for several other family members, whom the judge invited to attend court hearings and meetings if they wished. The court gave permission to the parties to share relevant documents with family members.
At the first hearing after hearing submissions from all the parties (including from the taxi driver and his wife that they did not want to be attorneys any more, the court revoked the LPAs.
The court decided it was in Mrs Jones’ best interests to have no contact with Mr and Mrs Taxi, until further order, and they gave formal Undertakings not to make contact with Mrs Jones by any means.
After that hearing, the taxi driver and his wife filed evidence saying they didn’t want any contact with Mrs Jones ever again. At the next hearing, the court removed them as parties, as no application was being made for a best interests decision about Mrs Jones’ contact with them. They then had no further role in the proceedings.
The court appointed the local authority as interim deputy for property and financial affairs. This was to make sure someone got on top of any potential fraud by the taxi driver and his wife. The deputy gathered financial information from banks and created a list of dubious transactions during the time that Mrs Jones was in hospital and could not have made the transactions herself.
The court appointed an independent expert psychologist to assess Mrs Jones’ capacity across a range of decisions. The psychologist had an expertise in coercive and controlling behaviour, so could comment on any potential interplay between undue influence and capacity.
The expert’s opinion was that Mrs Jones lacked capacity to decide on residence, care, contact with the taxi driver and his wife, and lacked capacity to manage her property and financial affairs: she could not understand what the trust deed was. The expert concluded that she retained her testamentary capacity (in other words, her capacity to write a will). This meant that she could instruct a solicitor to write a new will.
The parties asked the expert some questions of clarification in writing. The expert answered these questions in a second report, called an “addendum report”.
The parties then held a round table meeting on Teams with the expert to discuss the expert’s two reports. The parties agreed with the expert’s conclusions in all assessed areas of capacity. They agreed that there were no further best interests decisions for the court to make.
The parties agreed that the next court hearing could be vacated (cancelled), and sent the court an agreed draft final order.The court agreed with the draft, and issued the order.
There was no published judgment, as there was ultimately nothing for the court to decide. That doesn’t mean that the application was unnecessary. On the contrary: the court is a vital forum for determining capacity, and for making decisions in P’s best interests where they lack capacity to make those decisions. You can read more about how the Court of Protection works here.
Proceedings end, life goes on
Mrs Jones continues to like living in her care home. That said, she continues to display some behaviours that are likely post-traumatic signs caused by domestic abuse: she keeps herself to herself, and tells the staff that she doesn’t want to be a burden. The care home staff are aware of the trauma, and are seeking specialist input. Mrs Jones’ nephew lives nearby and visits her regularly.
With the family’s consent, the local authority is making an application to become permanent deputy. Other agencies are involved and are taking steps to try and address the psychological and financial harm that the taxi driver and his wife caused to Mrs Jones.